TABLE 2

Case reports/series and clinical trials of humans with a surfactant-processing mutation involved in fibrotic interstitial pneumonia

DiagnosisDrugOutcome after treatment per drug combinationOverall outcome after treatment[Ref.]
Adult case reports and series
  SFTPC p.I73TAdult with CPFEPrednisoneNo effectNo effect[55]
  SFTPA2 p.G231V1 adult with hypersensitivity pneumonitisPrednisone and avoidance of birdsImprovement1 improvement/1 no effect[7]
1 adult with pulmonary fibrosis and bronchoalveolar carcinomaPrednisoneNo effect
  ABCA3 p.G964DAdult with pulmonary fibrosisAntibioticsNo effectStabilisation[10]
Prednisone and azithromycinStabilisation
  ABCA3 p.G964DAdult with restrictive lung diseaseSteroids and azithromycin(Short-term) improvementStabilisation[85]
  HPS#Adult with HPSAntibiotics and oxygen inhalationNo effectNo effect[92]
  HPS1 IVS5+5 G>AAdult with HPSPrednisolone, cyclosporine ANo effect[91]
+ pirfenidoneShort-term stabilisationShort-term stabilisation
  HPS4 p.Q620XAdult with HPSCorticosteroids, pirfenidoneStabilisationStabilisation[90]
  HPS1 p.L668PAdult with HPSPrednisolone, pirfenidone, azathioprineNo effectNo effect[93]
  HPS#Adult with HPSOral corticosteroidsNo effectNo effect[94]
  HPS4 p.685delCAdult with HPSHigh-dose steroids and azathioprineNo effectNo effect[95]
  HPS#Adult with HPS and pulmonary sarcoidosisPrednisoneImprovementImprovement[89]
  HPS#Adult with HPSPrednisolone and pirfenidoneNo effectNo effect[96]
Paediatric case reports/series with SFTPC mutations
  SFTPC p.I73T p.I38F, p.V39L4 children with DIP, 1 child with chronic interstitial pneumonitis (p.V39L)1/5 systemic steroidsNo effect2 short-term improvement/3 improvement[36]
5/5 hydroxychloroquine2 short-term improvement, 3 improvement
  SFTPC p.A116DChild with NSIPHydroxychloroquine and supplemental oxygenImprovementImprovement[37]
  SFTPC p.I73TChild with ILDCorticosteroids and supplemental oxygenImprovementImprovement[55]
  SFTPC c.460+1 G → AChild with cellular or NSIPCorticosteroids and supplemental oxygenImprovementImprovement[5]
  SFTPC p.I73T5 children with chronic ILD5/5 methylprednisolone, 4/5 hydroxychloroquine, 5/5 supplemental oxygen5 improvement5 improvement[38]
  Different SFTPC BRICHOS/non-BRICHOS17 children with ILD (NSIP, PAP or DIP)14/17 hydroxychloroquine12/14 improvement
2/14 no effect
7 improvement/7 stabilisation/3 no effect[39]
15/17 systemic steroids14/15 improvement
1/15 no effect
7/17 surfactant2/7 improvement, 5/7 no effect
3/17 colchicine3 no effect
  SFTPC 14 non-BRICHOS, 6 BRICHOS22 children with chronic ILD at diagnosis18/22 methylprednisolone, 11/22 hydroxychloroquine, 5/22 azithromycin, 20/22 supplemental oxygen6/22 no effect, 16/22 improvement16 improvement/6 no effect[40]
  SFTPC p.G97SChild with CPI pattern with globular alveolar proteinosisHome ventilator support, oxygen, pulse methylprednisolone, azithromycin, hydroxychloroquineImprovementImprovement[41]
  SFTPC p.I73T, p.I38F2 children with CPIHydroxychloroquine, prednisone, ranitidine, TMP-SMX; 2 months after therapy began, pulse therapy of methylprednisolone; later, hydroxychloroquine alone2 improvement2 improvement[42]
  SFTPC p.I73TChild with CPI, pneumatoceles after biopsyMethylprednisolone, hydroxychloroquine, azithromycinImprovementImprovement[43]
  SFTPC p.I73TChild with ILDHydroxychloroquine, oxygen supplementationImprovement1 improvement/1 stabilisation/1 no effect[44]
Child with ARDS/DIPSupplemental oxygen and steroidsNo effect
Steroids pulse therapyShort-term improvement
HydroxychloroquineImprovement
Hydroxychloroquine replaced by azithromycinStabilisation
Child with DIPHydroxychloroquine and steroidsNo effect
  SFTPC p.I73TChild with chILDBronchodilators, inhaled corticosteroids and antileukotrienes, azathioprine, hydroxychloroquine and i.v. immunoglobulins, exogenous surfactantNo effectNo effect[52]
  SFTPC p.I73TChild with PAP and NSIPSupplemental oxygen, whole-lung lavages, systemic corticosteroids and azathioprineShort-term improvementShort-term improvement[45]
Additional corticosteroid pulse therapy plus azathioprineNo effect
  SFTPC Δexon 4Child with respiratory distressOral and i.v. corticosteroids, hydroxychloroquine, supplemental oxygenImprovementImprovement[51]
  SFTPC p.E66K, p.I73T, p.V102M, p.A155P8 children with idiopathic diffuse lung diseases2 children supplemental oxygen, pulse steroids and hydroxychloroquine2 limited effect2 limited effect/6 stabilisation[46]
Supplemental oxygen, pulse steroids, hydroxychloroquineStabilisation
Supplemental oxygen, hydroxychloroquineStabilisation
Supplemental oxygen, steroids, hydroxychloroquine, azithromycinStabilisation
Supplemental oxygen, pulse steroids, hydroxychloroquineStabilisation
Supplemental oxygen, pulse steroids, bronchodilators, antibioticsStabilisation
Steroids, supplemental oxygenStabilisation
  SFTPC p.L188Q2 children with respiratory distress (NSIP-like pattern)Methylprednisolone and hydroxychloroquine2 no effect2 no effect[53]
  SFTPC#Child with CPICorticosteroids, hydroxychloroquine and continuous oxygenShort-term improvementShort-term improvement[47]
  SFTPC p.I73TChild with NSIP/PAPSupplemental oxygen, antibiotics and oral corticosteroidsNo effectNo effect[54]
  SFTPC p.I73TChild with PAP/ILDWhole-lung lavages, systemic corticosteroids and azathioprineImprovementImprovement[48]
  SFTPC p.G182R, p.L188Q, p.C189W1 child with PAP/NSIPClearance, steroids, hydroxychloroquine, mechanical ventilationImprovement3 improvement[49]
1 child with respiratory failureClearance, steroids, azathioprine, mechanical ventilationImprovement
1 child with respiratory failureSteroids, azithromycin, hydroxychloroquine, mechanical ventilationImprovement
  SFTPC p.L81VChild with surfactant protein C deficiencyHydroxychloroquine, oxygen therapyImprovementImprovement[87]
  SFTPC#Child with NSIPSystemic steroids, azathioprine, hydroxychloroquineImprovementImprovement[88]
  Different SFTPC mutations15 children with interstitial chronic lung diseaseAll methylprednisolone
5/15 azithromycin
8/15 hydroxychloroquine
11 no effect/4 improvement11 no effect/4 improvement[50]
Paediatric case reports/series with ABCA3 mutations
  ABCA3#/SFTPCChild with DPLD/surfactant dysfunctionSurfactantImprovement2 short-term improvement/1 no effect[88]
Systemic steroidsNo effect
  ABCA3#Child with CPISystemic steroids, surfactantImprovement
ChloroquineNo effect
Child with DIPSystemic steroids, hydroxychloroquineNo effect
  ABCA3 c.358_359delChild with ABCA3 deficiencyMethylprednisolone, oxygen therapyLimited effectLimited effect[87]
  ABCA3 p.W1148X and p.T1114AChild with PAP-like featuresMethylprednisolone, antibiotics, antivirals and antifungals, oxygen, mechanical ventilationNo effectImprovement[76]
BAL with bovine surfactantImprovement
HydroxychloroquineImprovement
  ABCA3 p.G964DChild with (possible) IPFPrednisone and macrolidesImprovementImprovement[10]
  ABCA3 p.A307VChild with respiratory distressDexamethasone and surfactant, CPAPShort-term improvementImprovement[75]
Methylprednisolone, azithromycin, hydroxychloroquineImprovement
  ABCA3 p.Y1515XChild with RDSPulse steroids, antibioticsNo effectNo effect[77]
  ABCA3 p.R194G and V1615GfsX152 children with IRDSCPAP, corticosteroids and hydroxychloroquine2 limited effect2 limited effect[78]
  ABCA3 p.D253HChild with DPLDMethylprednisolone, oral prednisone, oxygen therapyNo effectImprovement[74]
AzithromycinImprovement
  ABCA3 p.R280C and p.E690GChild with DIPOxygen supplementation, surfactant therapy, corticosteroidsNo effectImprovement[73]
HydroxychloroquineImprovement
  ABCA3 p.D507del CA Ter 508, p.D696NChild with DIPDexamethasone, supplemental oxygen, surfactant therapyShort-term improvementImprovement[72]
Methylprednisolone, azithromycin, hydroxychloroquineImprovement
  ABCA3 p.K914R, p.L1238_E1239insGGChild with ILDMethylprednisolone, antibioticsLimited effectImprovement[71]
+ hydroxychloroquineImprovement
  ABCA3 c.59G>T and c.2646_2647insCChild with severe RDSHome ventilator, methylprednisolone, hydroxychloroquine, azithromycinImprovementImprovement[70]
  ABCA3 p.H778R, p.L1252PChild with DIP-like patternMethylprednisolone, prednisone and hydroxychloroquine, clarithromycinImprovementImprovement[69]
  Different ABCA3 mutations9 children with PAP pattern, DIP pattern and NSIP patternAll corticosteroids, 7/9 hydroxychloroquine4 no effect, 2 stabilisation, 3 improvement4 no effect, 2 stabilisation, 3 improvement[68]
  ABCA3, p.L798P, p.R1612PChild with DIPAntibiotics, supplemental oxygen, exogenous surfactant, methylprednisolone, hydroxychloroquineNo effectNo effect[79]
  ABCA3 p.R1561StopChild with respiratory distress with cyanosisAntibiotics, surfactant, dexamethasone, inhaled nitric oxide, methylprednisolone, hydroxychloroquineShort-term improvementShort-term improvement[67]
  ABCA3 large deletion exon 2–5Child with IRDSN-CPAP, surfactant therapy, dexamethasoneNo effectNo effect[80]
  ABCA3 ΔF1203 and c.1375ins15Child with IRDSSupplemental oxygen and systemic corticosteroids and diureticsNo effectNo effect[81]
  ABCA3 p.R20L and c.4483del25Child with ILDPrednisolone and supplemental oxygenNo effectNo effect[82]
  ABCA3 heterozygous p.E292VChild with cerebropulmonary dysgenetic syndromeCPAP, mechanical ventilation and antibioticsNo effectNo effect[84]
  ABCA3 p.S1116FChild with RDSSupplemental oxygen, mechanical ventilation, exogenous surfactant, antibiotics and inhaled nitric oxideNo effectNo effect[83]
  ABCA3 mutation#19 children (14 RDS, 4 RDS/PAP, 1 PAP)16/19 surfactant7 no effect, 9 improvement/short-term improvement29 no effect/3 improvement/3 stabilisation[85]
19/19 systemic steroids14 no effect, 5 improvement/short-term improvement
9/19 hydroxychloroquine5 no effect, 4 improvement/short-term improvement
2/19 azithromycin2 no effect
  Heterozygous ABCA3 mutation#16 children (9 with RDS, 4 with RDS/PAP, 1 PAP, 2 chILD)12/16 surfactant8 no effect, 4 improvement/short term improvement
12/16 systemic steroids8 no effect, 4 improvement/short-term improvement
8/16 hydroxychloroquine3 no effect, 5 improvement/short-term improvement
  ABCA3 p.M1227R and
 Ins1510fs/ter1519
Child with DIPMacrolides, dexamethasone, mechanical ventilationNo effectShort-term improvement[66]
SurfactantShort-term improvement
  ABCA3 heterozygous R288K (7 patients) p.R43L, R288K + c.4751delT (1 patient), R288K, P766S (heterozygous, 1 patient), R288K, S693L (heterozygous, 1 patient), R288K, Q215K (1 patient)11 children with ILD5/11 prednisolone, surfactant, oxygen or corticosteroidsNo effect5 no effect/6 improvement[65]
6/11 oxygen, aspirin, surfactant, dexamethasone, montelukast, salbutamol, steroids, hydroxychloroquine, azathioprine, azithromycin or antibioticsImprovement
Paediatric case report with AP3B1 mutation
  AP3B1 p.R509X and p.E659XChild with HPS2Oxygen, systemic corticosteroids, G-CSFStabilisationStabilisation[13]
Clinical trials
  HPS121 adults with HPS11 treated with pirfenidone, 10 placeboPirfenidone superior to placebo: ΔFVC of 0.46% per month (p=0.587)
Restricted group including only patients with initial FVC values >50% pred: difference in pulmonary function ∼0.7% per month (p=0.02)
[97]
  HPS1 or 4+35 adults with HPS23 treated with pirfenidone, 12 placeboNo statistically significant difference in lung function[98]

ABCA3 mutations were compound heterozygous or homozygous mutations, unless otherwise stated. CPFE: combined pulmonary fibrosis and emphysema; HPS: Hermansky–Pudlak syndrome; DIP: desquamative interstitial pneumonia; NSIP: nonspecific interstitial pneumonia; ILD: interstitial lung disease; PAP: pulmonary alveolar proteinosis; CPI: chronic pneumonitis of infancy; ARDS: acute respiratory distress syndrome; chILD: childhood ILD; DPLD: diffuse parenchymal lung disease; BAL: bronchoalveolar lavage; IPF: interstitial pulmonary fibrosis; (N)-CPAP: (nasal)-continuous positive airway pressure; RDS: respiratory distress syndrome; IRDS: infant respiratory distress syndrome; G-CSF: granulocyte colony-stimulating factor; ΔFVC: change in forced vital capacity. #: specific mutation not mentioned in the article, diagnosis based on absence of platelet dense bodies under electron microscopy or genetic testing; : 20 of these patients were Puerto Ricans homozygous for a 16-bp duplication in exon 15 of the HPS1 gene, which leads to a frameshift. The other patient was a Puerto Rican with a 3904-bp deletion in the HPS3 gene; +: 33 of these patients were Puerto Ricans homozygous for the known 16-bp duplication in exon 15 of the HPS1 gene. Two patients were non-Puerto Rican, and the mutations in these patients are not reported.