Abstract
Background Our group has identified the receptor for advanced glycation end-products (RAGE) as a predictor of World Trade Center particulate matter associated lung injury. The aim of this systematic review is to assess the relationship between RAGE and obstructive airways disease secondary to environmental exposure.
Methods A comprehensive search using PubMed and Embase was performed on January 5, 2018 utilising keywords focusing on environmental exposure, obstructive airways disease and RAGE and was registered with PROSPERO (CRD42018093834). We included original human research studies in English, focusing on pulmonary end-points associated with RAGE and environmental exposure.
Results A total of 213 studies were identified by the initial search. After removing the duplicates and applying inclusion and exclusion criteria, we screened the titles and abstracts of 61 studies. Finally, 19 full-text articles were included. The exposures discussed in these articles include particulate matter (n=2) and cigarette smoke (n=17).
Conclusion RAGE is a mediator of inflammation associated end-organ dysfunction such as obstructive airways disease. Soluble RAGE, a decoy receptor, may have a protective effect in some pulmonary processes. Overall, RAGE is biologically relevant in environmental exposure associated lung disease. Future investigations should focus on further understanding the role and therapeutic potential of RAGE in particulate matter exposure associated lung disease.
Abstract
RAGE is biologically relevant in environmental exposure associated lung disease. Future investigations should focus on further understanding the role and therapeutic potential of RAGE in particulate matter exposure associated lung disease http://ow.ly/gfZz30o7otU
Background
Obstructive airway disease (OAD) due to environmental exposure is a global health concern [1–3]. Mounting evidence supports the role of receptor for advanced glycation end-products (RAGE), also known as the advanced glycation end-product receptor (AGER), in the development of OAD [4–6].
RAGE is a member of the immunoglobulin superfamily and has several isoforms which recognise pathogens and endogenous ligands. RAGE is at the highest baseline level in the lungs, where it is expressed by alveolar type epithelial cells, alveolar macrophages and the smooth muscle cells of the airways [7, 8]. The membrane bound form is a key mediator of inflammation, metabolic dysfunction and vascular injury [9–11].
Given its pro-inflammatory role and abundance in the lungs, RAGE has been shown to be an important biomarker of airflow obstruction in various diseases such as cystic fibrosis, asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and particulate matter (PM)-associated OAD [12–16]. Furthermore, RAGE has been implicated in a murine smoke-exposure model of emphysema [17].
In human subjects with OAD, explanted lungs were noted to have increased expression and bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) levels of RAGE [4, 18]. In addition, the association between RAGE and OAD has been studied at the genomic level. Single nucleotide polymorphisms within the AGER locus have been linked to forced expiratory volume in 1 s (FEV1) in two genome-wide association studies (GWAS) [19, 20]. AGER-associated loci using in vitro models have been investigated to further our understanding of possible mechanisms. The promoter variant AGER-429 T/C (rs1800625) is associated with severity of airflow obstruction in cystic fibrosis and cells with this functional variant have elevated RAGE expression [21–23].
While the membrane-bound form of RAGE has been implicated in airway inflammation and obstruction, the circulating soluble form (s)RAGE has been shown to act as a decoy receptor. Studies show that OAD, particularly COPD, is associated with reduced levels of circulating sRAGE [12, 13]. The utility of sRAGE as a diagnostic biomarker in OAD is currently being investigated [14, 24]. The exact correlation of sRAGE and lung disease appears to vary depending on the pulmonary insult. There is evidence that sRAGE is involved in pathogenesis of acute lung injury (ALI). One study showed that sRAGE was inversely correlated with the rate of alveolar fluid clearance [25]. In a direct ALI model elevated sRAGE levels were seen in BAL samples 24 h after lipopolysaccharide-induced injury. Furthermore, treatment with mouse recombinant sRAGE 1 h post-injury attenuated neutrophilic infiltration, inflammatory mediator production and alveolar capillary permeability [26]. A subsequent study showed that RAGE was only elevated in BAL fluid of mice with direct ALI compared to an indirect ALI model [27].
The role of RAGE has been examined in several occupational lung diseases as well as pulmonary fibrosis. Some studies have suggested a protective effect, as evidenced by low expression of RAGE and sRAGE in human and mouse models of pulmonary fibrosis [28, 29]. Consistent with this hypothesis, mice deficient in Ager (Ager−/−) develop rapidly progressive fibrosis with asbestos exposure [30]. In contrast, another study showed that Ager−/− mice exhibited less fibrosis when exposed to bleomycin as compared to wild-type controls [31]. Furthermore, Ager−/− mice do not demonstrate any difference in the severity of fibrosis with silica exposure [30]. In models of atopic asthma, Ager−/− mice did not demonstrate airway hypersensitivity, eosinophilic inflammation and airway remodelling. In fact, Ager inhibition in wild-type mice significantly reduced inflammation [15].
Finally, our group has identified elevated serum lysophosphatidic acid (LPA), a product of low-density lipoprotein and a known ligand of RAGE and sRAGE, as World Trade Center-Lung Injury (WTC-LI) biomarkers in the Fire Department of New York (FDNY) cohort [32–34]. Therefore, we have focused this systematic review on RAGE, a biologically plausible mediator and biomarker of environmentally associated OAD.
Methods
Review strategy
A systematic review of the literature was performed adhering to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analysis (PRISMA) guidelines [35, 36]. Our population, intervention, control, outcome (PICO) question was “In adult patients with obstructive airways disease (P), we performed a systematic review to identify (I) the role of the advanced glycation end-products receptor in subjects whose OAD is secondary to an environmental exposure (O)”. Given the design of our systematic review, no comparison control (C) was needed. PubMed and Embase were searched on January 5, 2018. The details of the protocol of our systematic review were registered on PROSPERO (CRD42018093834) and can be accessed at www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/display_record.php?RecordID=93834.
Search terms
Databases were searched for the following: (particulate matter OR air pollutants OR air pollution OR occupational pollution OR environmental pollution OR ambient air OR pollution OR particle size OR air filters OR smoking OR cigarette smoke) AND (advanced glycation end products receptor or rage or ager) AND (lung OR respiratory OR lung diseases OR obstructive lung disease OR obstructive airway disease OR obstructive airways disease OR asthma OR chronic bronchitis OR COPD OR chronic obstructive pulmonary disease OR emphysema).
For the purposes of this review, we defined obstructive airways diseases to include asthma, emphysema, chronic bronchitis and COPD; environmental exposures included cigarette smoke, particulate matter/dust, air or other occupational pollution. We chose to include cigarette use as an environmental exposure, since there is literature that passive smoking or environmental tobacco smoke is associated with an increased risk of COPD similar to direct tobacco use [37–39].
We included studies that 1) discussed advanced glycation end products receptor or any of its isoforms in the setting of OAD due to environmental exposures and 2) assessed OAD development after environmental exposure. We excluded studies that 1) were not original research; 2) not written in the English language; 3) focused on non-human subjects or in vitro work; or were 4) conducted in a paediatric population.
Data extraction
Each article was screened for study design, patient characteristics, sample size, tools used, severity and prevalence of OAD. Results from each database search were filtered for human subjects and English language, and imported into EndNote X8 (Clarivate Analytics, Philadelphia, PA, USA). The references were then screened for duplicates using RefWorks (ProQuest LLC, Ann Arbor, MI, USA). Only original research papers were then reviewed (title, abstract and full text) to ascertain eligibility. In addition, we examined the references cited in the relevant articles. All results were screened by SHH and further independently evaluated by AN and AO. Disagreements were resolved by consensus (supplementary tables S1–S5).
Results/synthesis
Study inclusion, characteristics and sources of bias
A total of 213 studies were identified from PubMed, Embase and reference-list screening (figure 1). After application of selection criteria, 61 research papers were assessed for inclusion. Of these, 41 were excluded after the initial review. Finally, 19 original research articles were considered eligible to be included. There are two types of environmental exposures discussed in these articles, particulate matter (n=2) and cigarette smoke (n=17). Of these, six investigations discuss RAGE as a biomarker of OAD activity, seven evaluate the association of RAGE with OAD, four are GWAS discussing RAGE and its isoforms in COPD and smoking, and two discuss the role of RAGE in multiple end-organ outcomes. Data from all searches, screening and extraction are available (table 1 and supplementary table S1).
Flow diagram as per PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) guidelines [40]. OAD: obstructive airways disease; AGER: advanced glycation end-product receptor.
Relevance of the receptor for advanced glycation end-products (RAGE) in obstructive airways disease secondary to environmental exposure
Associations between receptor for advanced glycation end-products (RAGE), soluble (s)RAGE and disease state
RAGE in the context of particulate matter exposure
Autophagy is critical in the pathogenesis of PM-related COPD, leading to impairment of diffusion. One retrospective study in Taiwan investigated the association of clinically relevant biomarkers in COPD patients (Global Initiative for Chronic Obstructive Lung Disease stages III/IV) exposed to particles with a 50% cut-off aerodynamic diameter of 10 µm (PM10). The 1-year average PM10 exposure was positively correlated with interleukin (IL)-6, ubiquitin and beclin-1 levels, and negatively correlated with diffusing capacity of the lung for carbon monoxide (DLCO), circulating RAGE level and arterial oxygen saturation [41]. Recently, our group studied the role of sRAGE in the WTC-PM exposed firefighters as well as in a murine model of PM exposure. sRAGE is associated with WTC-LI in humans and mice alike, and in the murine model, absence of RAGE was protective against loss of lung function and airway hyperreactivity due to WTC-PM exposure [6].
RAGE as a biomarker of emphysema
Studies have evaluated sRAGE as a potential diagnostic biomarker in order to avoid chest imaging and possibly detect emphysema at earlier stages [18, 51–53]. A prior systematic review concluded that sRAGE is a strong biomarker of emphysema, but only in patients with airflow limitation [14]. Furthermore, peripheral plasma samples of individuals from the COPDGene population have been assessed for the association of specific biomarkers with emphysema noted on computed tomography (CT) imaging (percentage low lung attenuation ≤−910 HU). Patients with more emphysema had lower sRAGE and intercellular adhesion molecule-1 levels [45]. These results were further validated in the Treatment of Emphysema with a Gamma-Selective Retinoid Agonist (TESRA) cohort [45] (table 1).
RAGE correlates with severity of emphysema
In the Evaluation of COPD Longitudinally to Identify Predictive Surrogate Endpoints (ECLIPSE) cohort of COPD patients, the change in CT lung density and severity of emphysema over the study period was correlated with a number of circulating biomarkers. At baseline, patients with higher levels of sRAGE and surfactant protein D had less emphysema, while lower levels of CCL-18 correlated with more severe disease. Elevated sRAGE, fibrinogen and IL-6 levels at baseline were associated with less progression of emphysema [48].
In another study, serum samples of patients with stable COPD, smokers without COPD and nonsmoking controls were compared for specific biomarkers. Extracellular RAGE-binding protein (EN-RAGE) and sRAGE levels were significantly different between those groups as well as at various stages of COPD. Overall, sRAGE levels were reduced in COPD patients and were more associated with variability in DLCO values. On the contrary, EN-RAGE levels were significantly elevated in severe COPD and more associated with FEV1 and FEV1/forced vital capacity (FVC) values. These findings suggest that sRAGE and EN-RAGE may affect different lung function measures (airway obstruction or diffusion capacity) [49] (tables 1 and 2).
Role of sRAGE in WTC-PM exposed firefighters
Our group has identified RAGE as a biomarker of WTC-PM induced FEV1 decline. Using a case–cohort design, we studied a cohort of never-smoking male FDNY firefighters exposed to WTC dust with normal pre-9/11 lung function. The odds of developing WTC-LI increased by 1.2, 1.8 and 1.0 in firefighters with sRAGE ≥97 pg·mL−1, C-reactive protein ≥2.4 mg·L−1 and matrix metalloproteinase-9 ≥397 ng·mL−1, respectively. We concluded that increased sRAGE is associated with WTC-LI [6] (tables 1 and 2).
RAGE is a biomarker of vascular injury
A pilot study examined patients with COPD, smokers without COPD and nonsmokers who had renal biopsy or nephrectomy. They measured AGE-RAGE and tissue oxidative stress levels in pulmonary and renal endothelial cells and showed that they were indeed elevated in the COPD group. In addition, they revealed similar findings in the cigarette smoke-exposed mice. The investigators concluded that COPD patients and cigarette smoke-exposed mice have pulmonary and renal endothelial cell injury associated with the tissue oxidative stress AGE-RAGE pathway [42].
Correlation of RAGE and nitric oxide generation
The role of RAGE in cigarette smoke-induced nitric oxide (NO) generation was studied by assessing the bronchial epithelia of smokers with COPD and compared to healthy smokers and nonsmokers with COPD. RAGE overexpression was noted only in smokers with COPD and positively correlated with NO levels, smoking status and lung function decline. Human bronchial epithelial cells that were cultured in cigarette smoke extract had low sRAGE levels, but enhanced RAGE and NO levels. Interestingly, increased NO level and NO synthase activity were all reversed by pretreatment with anti-RAGE antibody [47].
Accumulation of RAGE in different body compartments
One study assessed AGE and sRAGE levels in plasma, sputum, bronchial biopsies and skin and tested whether differential tissue accumulation is associated with COPD [43]. Skin autofluorescence of AGE and sRAGE in blood and sputum was measured by ELISA, and by immunohistochemistry in the bronchial biopsies. COPD patients had increased accumulation of AGE in the skin compared to non-COPD smokers and never-smokers. This difference in expression was not seen in bronchial tissues of different groups. Lower FEV1 % predicted and FEV1/FVC ratio were independently associated with a higher AGE levels in skin [43]. sRAGE levels were significantly lower in the plasma of COPD patients compared to young and old healthy subjects. Additionally, these levels were negatively correlated with the severity of COPD. Patients with lower sRAGE levels had lower FEV1, lower DLCO and higher AGE accumulation in the skin. The authors hypothesised that sRAGE has a protective effect and functions as a decoy receptor, preventing accumulation of AGE in the skin [43].
RAGE as a biomarker of cardiovascular disease in COPD
The results of studies assessing sRAGE and cardiovascular disease are heterogeneous. One study looked specifically at COPD patients and non-COPD smokers with calculated cardiovascular risk prediction scores [44]. The cardiovascular risk prediction scores and sRAGE levels were the same in both groups. They found no associations between sRAGE and diabetes or aortic pulse wave velocity [44]. In the absence of ischaemic heart disease or diabetes, COPD patients had significantly lower levels of sRAGE, which is consistent with prior literature.
sRAGE as a marker of longitudinal loss of lung function
A longitudinal cohort study of nonsmokers, smokers without COPD and smokers with COPD in northern Finland was performed with measurements of high mobility group box (HMGB)1 (a ligand of RAGE), sRAGE, and lung function testing. There were no significant differences in the HMGB1 levels between the study groups, but patients with severe airflow obstruction had higher levels than others [46]. This result is consistent with prior findings. Lower sRAGE levels were associated with longitudinal decline of FEV1/FVC ratio in all groups (table 2). This was particularly evident in smokers with COPD, as lower sRAGE levels predicted longitudinal decline in FEV1.
Genetic polymorphism of RAGE in COPD
The genetic polymorphism of RAGE is less well studied in COPD compared to inflammatory diseases such as Crohn's disease. There are 1517 single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) detected in the RAGE gene, but they are mostly nonsense mutations [56]. Three functional SNPs in the promoter region (−429 T/C and −374 T/A) and one SNP in exon 3 (G82S) of the AGER gene have been studied. One study in a Chinese population showed that G82S polymorphism was significantly higher in COPD patients and associated with higher risk of developing COPD in current smokers [56]. In another study of a Polish population with severe COPD, a number of SNPs associated with lung function were investigated including AGER, ADCY2 and THSD4. They identified associations between CHRNA3/5, IREB2, FAM13A and COPD, as well as ADCY2 with severe COPD [55]. A GWAS on two quantitative emphysema and airway imaging phenotypes using the COPDGene, ECLIPSE, National Emphysema Treatment Trial (NETT) and Genetics of Chronic Obstructive Lung Disease (GenKOLS) cohorts found five loci of interest. AGER was associated with COPD and spirometric measures related to airflow obstruction as well as emphysema and sRAGE levels [54]. Furthermore, the Ser82 RAGE variant was associated with higher FEV1, FEV1/FVC ratio and lower serum sRAGE levels in UK smokers. The investigators also found that HMGB1 activation of the RAGE-Ser82 receptor resulted in lower sRAGE levels.
RAGE as a biomarker of asthma
Although asthma was not the clinical focus of any of the studies that met all inclusion/exclusion criteria of our systematic review, the development of an asthmatic phenotype may occur in the context of an environmental exposure. In the review of this literature we found that patients with neutrophilic asthma and COPD had significantly lower levels of sRAGE in BAL, plasma and serum relative to healthy controls and those with non-neutrophilic asthma and COPD. HMGB1, a potent mediator of neutrophilic inflammatory response and a RAGE ligand, was slightly increased in neutrophilic patients. Consistent with our understanding of the role of sRAGE, lack of inhibition of downstream inflammatory effects of RAGE may play a role in development of neutrophilic asthma [13]. In addition, RAGE has been implicated in the pathophysiology of eosinophilic asthma. In a murine model, wild-type (WT) and RAGE knockout mice were exposed to house dust mite (HDM) extract and sensitised with ovalbumin. HDM-exposed WT mice exhibited increased airway resistance and small airway tissue damping in response to methacholine challenge relative to RAGE knockouts. Absence of RAGE was associated with absence of inflammatory infiltrates, lack of elevated mucin expression or goblet cell hyperplasia. IL-5, IL-13 and eotaxin were significantly elevated in HDM-exposed WT mice, and to a lesser degree in RAGE knockout mice [15]. In another murine study, WT and RAGE knockout mice were sensitised with ovalbumin. The WT mice exhibited significantly elevated levels of interferon-γ and IL-5 when compared to RAGE knockout mice [16] (table 2).
Discussion
Our systematic review identified 19 original articles where the role of RAGE is found to be important in the development of environmental exposure related OAD. These studies differed significantly in the populations, methods and outcomes that were studied (table 1). However, these studies allow us to further define the role of RAGE in the development of OAD related to a heterogeneous environmental exposure. These studies suggest that RAGE may be a multifaceted contributor to OAD development.
Particulate matter exposure causes systemic inflammation, endothelial dysfunction and subsequent end-organ damage leading to OAD [58–60]. These effects are particularly evident as loss of lung function associated with WTC-PM exposure [61–72]. There is mounting evidence that RAGE is a biologically plausible mediator of inflammation and vascular injury, and is associated with conditions such as metabolic syndrome and OAD.
In most organs, RAGE is expressed at low baseline levels and increases with disease activity as seen in the lungs of COPD patients [4]. The highest expression of RAGE occurs in the lungs, but its deleterious effects are not just limited to this organ. For instance, AGE-RAGE levels are elevated in the pulmonary and renal endothelial cells of patients with COPD [42]. Accumulation of AGEs in different organs appears to vary and correlates with the levels of circulating sRAGE. A prior study showed that accumulation of AGEs in the skin is directly correlated with low circulating sRAGE levels in COPD patients. This has led to the hypothesis that sRAGE acts a decoy receptor and appears to be protective against the inflammatory effect of membrane bound RAGE. Patients with higher PM exposure and associated COPD have lower levels of sRAGE. These levels correlate well with severity of COPD and predict longitudinal decline in FEV1 (tables 1 and 2).
A finer understanding of the RAGE pathway and its role in inflammation-associated OAD may allow us to identify therapeutic targets to halt progression of diseases such COPD. In one study, administration of sRAGE or deletion of the RAGE gene mitigated LPA–RAGE interaction and disease development [33]. RAGE has been the focus of targeted therapeutic trials [9, 73–75].
RAGE is a key mediator of MetSyn, which affects >30% of adults in the United States [76–78]. A diet high in caloric content is a key contributor to MetSyn. Several groups are actively studying the MetSyn and lung disease associated with environmental exposures. Several studies of WTC-exposed cohorts (a high particulate exposed group) have described a high incidence of obesity [77, 79]. In addition, we found that a multimetabolite model was able to differentiate between those with WTC-LI and those without [72]. One of the key mediators of the metabolome is diet, and we know that dietary interventions that have focused on weight loss in obstructed patients show improvement of both FEV1 and FVC by as much as 22% in as little as 15 days [80, 81]. Using a very low calorie diet, investigators have been able to achieve a 20 kg loss over a 6-month period; every 10% relative loss of weight led to a significant improvement of FVC by 92 mL and FEV1 by 73 mL [82]. As patients decreased their body mass index from 37 to 32 kg·m−2, the mean morning FEV1 and FVC significantly increased [83]. Improvement of lung function in obese subjects who undergo weight loss is due predominantly to changes in lung mechanics. Associated biochemical changes that may play a role are active areas of investigation and are a focus of our future work. Additionally, recent studies show the effectiveness of calorie-reduced and Mediterranean diets in reducing lipid levels [84]. While moderating fats can be essential to maintaining a healthy diet, there is extensive literature that explores the potential health benefits of high fats in a Mediterranean diet, such as n-3 and n-6 polyunsaturated fatty acids [85, 86].
Systematic reviews have inherent biases that we addressed through the design of our search algorithm. Our systematic review is affected by selection, detection, performance and reporting bias. Selection bias was addressed by having a predetermined inclusion and exclusion criteria and distinct definitions. Detection and performance bias were addressed by having at least two rounds of screening individually performed. Reporting bias was addressed through PubMed and Embase search filters that included peer-reviewed published articles that were written in English and which focused on human subjects. Removing duplicates further limited reporting bias.
The development of OAD due to environmental exposure is a leading cause of morbidity and mortality worldwide. RAGE is involved in the inflammatory cascade of events that lead to development of obstructive airway disease. Soluble RAGE acts as a decoy receptor and may have a protective effect against development of OAD. Patients with lower levels of soluble RAGE may have more severe COPD and emphysema. By targeting RAGE-mediated inflammation, we may mitigate progression of OAD.
Supplementary material
Supplementary Material
Please note: supplementary material is not edited by the Editorial Office, and is uploaded as it has been supplied by the author.
TABLE S1 Search criteria ERR-0096-2018.tableS1
TABLE S2 Embase filtered ERR-0096-2018.tableS2
TABLE S3 PubMed filtered ERR-0096-2018.tableS3
TABLE S4 Studies that met inclusion and exclusion criteria ERR-0096-2018.tableS4
TABLE S5 Clean screened ERR-0096-2018.tableS5
Footnotes
This article has supplementary material available from err.ersjournals.com
This study is registered at PROSPERO with identifier number CRD42018093834.
Provenance: Submitted article, peer reviewed.
Authors’ contributions: All authors made substantial contributions to the study. All authors participated in study conception and design, data analysis and interpretation, and manuscript preparation. Primary investigator AN; study design SHH, EJC, AN; statistical analysis SHH; data interpretation SHH, AO, JR, AV, AN. All authors participated in writing and revision of the report and approval of the final version.
Author disclaimers: The views expressed in this article do not communicate an official position of the institution, or funding source.
Conflict of interest: S.H. Haider has nothing to disclose.
Conflict of interest: A. Oskuei has nothing to disclose.
Conflict of interest: G. Crowley has nothing to disclose.
Conflict of interest: S. Kwon has nothing to disclose.
Conflict of interest: R. Lam has nothing to disclose.
Conflict of interest: J. Riggs has nothing to disclose.
Conflict of interest: M. Mikhail has nothing to disclose.
Conflict of interest: A. Talusan has nothing to disclose.
Conflict of interest: A. Veerappan has nothing to disclose.
Conflict of interest: J.S. Kim has nothing to disclose.
Conflict of interest: E.J. Caraher has nothing to disclose.
Conflict of interest: A. Nolan has nothing to disclose.
Support statement: NHLBI R01HL119326, CDC/NIOSH U01-OH011300. The funding agencies did not participate in the study design; collection, analysis and interpretation of data; in the writing of the report; and in the decision to submit the article for publication. Funding information for this article has been deposited with the Crossref Funder Registry.
- Received October 15, 2018.
- Accepted February 9, 2019.
- Copyright ©ERS 2019.
This article is open access and distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial Licence 4.0.
References
