TABLE 1

Characteristics of the studies

First author [ref.]Study settingStudy designPatient populationPatients nViral testsAge yearsMale %AimsMortality %
Angeles Marcos [3]Spain, 2003–2004, inpatientProspective cohortPatients aged >14 years admitted to the hospital with CAP198PCR, IFA, culture, serology70 (median)58Incidence and characteristics of viral CAP, and yield of tests for viral infection2.5
van Gageldonk-Lafeber [5]The Netherlands, 2007–2010, inpatientProspective cohortPatients aged >18 years with CAP in the ED339PCR66 (median)62.5Aetiology of CAPNot reported
Hara [6]Thailand, 2006–2008, inpatientProspective cohortPatients aged >16 years admitted to the hospital with CAP119PCR55 (mean)71.4Aetiology of CAP18.5
Holm [22]Denmark, 2002–2003, inpatient and outpatientProspective cohortPatients aged >18 years with suspected CAP seen in outpatient clinic48PCR50 (median)49Aetiology of CAP and outcomes0
Mermond [7]New Caledonia, 2006–2007, inpatientProspective cohortPatients aged >16 years admitted to the hospital with CAP137PCR, IFA58 (median)58.4Aetiology of CAP, performance of tests, and assessment of vaccination-preventable proportion of causative organisms5.8
Jennings [8]New Zealand, 1999–2000, inpatientProspective cohortPatients aged >18 years admitted to the hospital with CAP304PCR, IFA, culture, serology70 (median)52Aetiology of CAP and characteristics of viral pneumonia6.8 (only reported for viral subset)
Luchsinger [9]Chile, 2005–2007, inpatient and outpatientProspective cohortPatients aged >18 years presenting with CAP356PCR, IFA, culture, serology61 (median)53.6Aetiology of CAP and relationship between severity and pathogen7.8
Takahashi [10]Vietnam, 2009–2010, inpatientProspective cohortPatients aged >15 years admitted to the hospital with CAP174PCR42 (median)52Incidence, aetiology and clinical features of CAP9.8
Wiemken [11]USA, 2008–2011, inpatient ICUProspective cohortPatients aged >18 years with CAP admitted to the ICU393PCR52 (mean)#56#Incidence of respiratory viruses in CAP patients in ICUNot reported
Choi [2]Republic of Korea, 2010–2011, inpatientRetrospective analysis of a prospective cohortPatients aged >18 years admitted to the hospital with severe CAP64PCR, culture49 (mean)76.6Role of viral infection in patients with severe CAP32.8
Templeton [1]The Netherlands, 2000–2002, inpatient and outpatientProspective cohortPatients aged >18 years with CAP105PCR, culture, IFA,
complement fixation
>60 (50% of patients)71Aetiology of CAP3.8
Musher [12]USA, 2011–2012, inpatientProspective cohortPatients admitted to a Veteran Affairs hospital259PCR70 (mean)95.7Yield of traditional and new diagnostic testsNot reported
Shibli [34]Israel, 2006–2007, inpatientProspective cohortPatients aged >18 years admitted to the hospital with CAP126PCR, DNA/RNA genomic extraction, serology58.3 (mean)57.9Identify common pathogens causing CAP in hospitalised patients and evaluate correlation of aetiology and disease severity3.96
Sangil [33]Spain, 2009–2010, inpatientProspective cohortPatients aged >18 years admitted to the hospital with CAP131Multiplex PCR, serology64.4 (mean)68.7Determine aetiology of CAP by adding PCR to conventional methods and describe clinical and laboratory features between patients with bacterial and viral CAP5.3
Johansson [26]Sweden, 2004–2005, inpatientProspective cohortPatients aged >18 years admitted to the hospital with CAP184PCR, serology, viral culture61.3 (mean)51Determine aetiology of CAP among adults using new PCR platform and conventional methods3.8
Huijskens [24]The Netherlands, 2008–2009, inpatientProspective cohortPatients aged >18 years admitted to the hospital with CAP408PCR, serology68 (median)61.3Evaluate potential for targeted diagnostics and directed treatment39
Saito [32]Japan, 1999–2000, outpatient and inpatientProspective cohortPatients aged >17 years admitted to the hospital with CAP232PCR, antigen immunoassay, serology60 (mean)57.8Identify aetiology of CAP1.7
Yin [36]China, 2008–2009, infectious disease outpatient clinicProspective cohortPatients aged >18 years admitted to the hospital with CAP215PCR36.1 (mean of those reported)47.1 (of those with aetiologies)Evaluate Japanese Respiratory Society guidelines for identification of Mycoplasma pneumoniae0
Diederen [20]The Netherlands, 1998–2000, inpatientProspective cohortPatients aged >18 years admitted to the hospital with CAP242PCR, immunoassay/ELISA, serologyNot reportedNot reportedDetection of respiratory viruses and Legionella by PCR in CAP patients9.5
Hohenthal [21]Finland, 1999–2004, inpatientProspective cohortPatients aged >16 years admitted to the hospital with CAP384PCR, immunoassay/IFA, serology49.8 (mean)52.3Assess utility of rapid micro tests in different disease severities of CAPNot reported
Lieberman [30]Israel, Nov 2004–March 2005 and Nov 2005–April 2006, inpatientProspective cohortPatients aged >18 years admitted to the hospital with CAP183PCR59.5 (mean)57Identify viruses in CAP versus control versus lower respiratory infectionsNot reported
Kim [29]Republic of Korea, 2010–2013, inpatient and outpatientRetrospective cohortPatients aged >18 years admitted to the hospital with CAP327PCR, immunoassay for influenza antigen67 (mean) in viral pneumonia;
70 (mean) in nonviral pneumonia
72% in viral CAP;
78% in nonviral CAP
Investigate predictors of viral CAP18.9
Karhu [28]Finland, 2008–2013, inpatient ICUProspective cohortPatients aged >18 years admitted to the hospital with severe CAP49PCR54 (median)42.9Evaluate presence and course of viral infections in ventilated patients using PCR12.2
Holter [23]Norway, 2008–2011, inpatientProspective cohortPatients aged >18 years admitted to the hospital with CAP264PCR, serology66 (mean)52Describe aetiology and evaluate diagnostic results3.7
Qu [31]China, 2010–2012, inpatient and outpatientProspective cohortPatients aged >14 years admitted to the hospital with CAP954PCR45.2 (mean)56.6Investigate respiratory virus aetiology in adolescents and adults with CAP, by age and PSI0.4
Charles [17]Australia, 2004–2006, inpatientProspective cohortPatients aged >18 years admitted to the hospital with CAP865PCR, serology for influenza65.1 (mean)60.7Evaluate aetiology, severity assessment
tools and outcomes of CAP
5.6
Viasus [35]Spain, 2010–2011, inpatientProspective cohortAdults admitted to the hospital with CAP747PCR65 (median)56.8Evaluate aetiology, clinical features and prognosis of CAP8.2
Das [19]France, 2011–1012, EDProspective cohortPatients aged >18 years presenting to the ED with CAP125PCR65 (mean)#49#Evaluate aetiology of CAPNot reported
Jain [25]USA, 2010–2012, inpatientProspective cohortPatients aged >18 years admitted to the hospital with CAP2259PCR, serology57 (median)Not reportedPopulation-based surveillance study of CAP aetiology2
Johnstone [27]Canada, 2004–2006, inpatientProspective cohortPatients aged >18 years admitted to the hospital with CAP193NAT, IFA71 (median)51Describe the pathogens, clinical presentation
and outcomes of patients with CAP
3
Cillóniz [18]Spain, 2003–2010, inpatient ICUProspective cohortPatients aged >18 years admitted to the ICU with CAP362PCR, IFA63 (mean)64Study the prevalence,
clinical characteristics and outcomes of severe CAP in the ICU
10
  • CAP: community-acquired pneumonia; IFA: immunofluorescence assay; ED: emergency department; ICU: intensive care unit; PSI: pneumonia severity index; NAT: nucleic acid amplification tests. #: for all patients, including some not included in our analysis.